silver nitrate notes

Ace in the Hole Built a Fairground Around One Trapped Man

19 oct 2026

The cruellest thing in Ace in the Hole (1951) is not Chuck Tatum. It is the Ferris wheel. Billy Wilder (1906-2002) lets a rescue turn into a carnival one shot at a time, a tent here, a row of parked cars there, a wheel turning slowly against a New Mexico sky, until the thing that was supposed to be about a man in a mountain has become a place you can buy a ticket to. The mountain never changes. The crowd around it keeps growing, and Wilder's camera keeps measuring the crowd.

Tatum, played by Kirk Douglas (1916-2020), is a New York reporter who has been fired from bigger papers and has landed at a small Albuquerque daily, with a plan to get back to the top by finding a story. He finds one when a local man, Leo Minosa (Richard Benedict), is trapped by a cave-in while hunting for Indian relics in an old cliff-dwelling site. Tatum crawls in, talks to Leo, files copy, and then does the unforgivable thing: he persuades the sheriff to rescue Leo by drilling down from the top of the mountain, a method that will take days, rather than shoring up the tunnel from the side, which would take hours. Every extra day is another day of headlines.

Wilder had been given the pattern by real life. The film borrows from the case of Floyd Collins, who was trapped in Sand Cave, Kentucky, in 1925 and whose ordeal drew an enormous crowd, and from the reporter William Miller of the Louisville Courier-Journal, who crawled in to reach him and won a Pulitzer Prize for the coverage. It also carries traces of the 1949 case of Kathy Fiscus, a little girl who fell into an abandoned well in San Marino, California, in an incident covered live on local television. Wilder, with his co-writers Lesser Samuels and Walter Newman, moved the whole thing to the desert and asked what would happen if the reporter on the scene were the one person who benefited from the delay.

Charles Lang (1902-1998) photographed it, and the choice of Lang is part of the argument. This is hard, flat, glaring light, shot under enormous skies, and the picture is nearly without softness anywhere. Lang had won an Academy Award for A Farewell to Arms in 1933 and would go on to shoot The Big Heat (1953) and, for Wilder again, Some Like It Hot (1959), and here he uses the glare as a kind of pitiless witness. The desert gives the crowd nowhere to hide. In the wide shots the carnival, the drilling rig and the mountain share a single plane of focus, so that the cost of the spectacle is on screen at the same moment as its cause.

The best performance is not Douglas's, though he is ferociously good. It is Jan Sterling's (1921-2004). She plays Lorraine, Leo's wife, who has been trapped in the little roadside trading post for years and has wanted out for as long as the film has known her. When the crowd arrives she does what anyone would do and starts selling things to it. Sterling plays her as the only person in the film who is entirely honest about what she wants, and she is also the only one who looks at Tatum and sees exactly what he is. Their scenes together are two people recognising one another across a very low bar.

Wilder lets the crowd sing. There is a novelty song, "We're Coming, Leo," that the visitors take up as though it were a hymn, and it is among the most unnerving things I know in American film of the period, because it is cheerful and sincere and wrong. Porter Hall plays the old newspaper editor who believes in the principles of his trade, and his small, dry rebukes of Tatum are the film's one source of moral weather. They do not change anything. That is, I think, the point.

Paramount released it in 1951 under Wilder's title and it did badly, after which the studio retitled it The Big Carnival and tried again. It was Wilder's first picture after the end of his partnership with Charles Brackett, and he was reported to have been stung by the reception. The film has been rediscovered in the decades since, and the usual explanation is that the world caught up with its cynicism. I would put it differently. The picture was never about the press, or not only. It is about the way a crowd arrives and makes a private disaster into an occasion, and about how little it costs the crowd to do it. That had been true in Kentucky in 1925. It was true in California in 1949. Wilder only had to build the Ferris wheel.

[ « prev: Detour · latest post ]

» leave a comment in the guestbook

sources
[1] Sikov, Ed. On Sunset Boulevard: The Life and Times of Billy Wilder. New York: Hyperion, 1998.
[2] Lally, Kevin. Wilder Times: The Life of Billy Wilder. New York: Henry Holt, 1996.
[3] Crowe, Cameron. Conversations with Wilder. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1999.
[4] Chandler, Charlotte. Nobody's Perfect: Billy Wilder, A Personal Biography. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2002.